DIY vs. Full-Service Payroll: What’s Best for Your Business?

DIY vs. Full-Service Payroll

As a business owner, picking the right payroll software is crucial. It’s about finding the right fit for your budget and business needs and ensuring your employees are paid correctly and on time.

The DIY Payroll Approach

Saving Money: If you’re considering the DIY route, it’s often seen as the more budget-friendly option. This could work well for you if you already know a lot about payroll processes.

In Control: With DIY payroll, you manage everything, giving you full control and allowing you to handle payroll on your own terms.

Time Matters: However, remember that DIY payroll can take up a lot of your time. You’ll need to handle all the calculations for wages and taxes yourself, which can be pretty time-consuming.

Full-Service Payroll: The Stress-Free Option

Expert Help: When you choose full-service payroll, you get a team of experts to manage your payroll. This means less worry for you about whether everything is done correctly and on time.

Save Your Time: By letting professionals handle your payroll, you free up time to focus on growing your business.

Cost vs. Value: Full-service payroll might seem pricier at first, but the extra cost is often worth it for the convenience, reliability, and time saved.

How to Decide?

Know Your Strengths: If you’re comfortable with payroll tasks and have the know-how, DIY might be a good choice. But if you’re not familiar with payroll details, it could lead to headaches and wasted time.

Size of Your Business: If you have a small business with straightforward payroll needs, you might manage well with DIY software. However, if your business is larger or has more complex payroll needs, a full-service option might be better.

Value Your Time: Think about how much your time is worth. If handling payroll is taking away from growing your business, it might be time to consider full-service payroll.

And that's it!

All in all, your choice between DIY and full-service payroll software should be based on what’s best for your business and your peace of mind. If you want to save time and avoid the hassle of managing payroll yourself, a full-service option like what we offer at Baron Payroll can be a great choice. When making your decision, consider your needs, budget, and how much time you can realistically dedicate to payroll.

Remember, the right payroll solution will not only handle the numbers but also give you more time to focus on what you do best: running your business. 

 Need help with your payroll? Use our instant pricing calculator to get an estimate for the cost of our full-service payroll services.

Get Your Instant Price

If you found this article helpful, here are some others you might like:


Are You Paying Too Much?

Send us your payroll invoice and get a FREE 10 min call to see if you’re getting ripped off.


Do you have ITIN workers?

Are you upset because your payroll company can't help?


How Much Does It Cost?

See detailed pricing now for each service without talking to a salesperson.

Baron can lighten my workload and increase my profitability?
Let’s talk shop.

Book Time With Bill Elkins