DIY vs. Professional Payroll Services: What's the Real Cost?

DIY vs. Professional Payroll Services: What's the Real Cost?

Deciding how to manage your payroll is a big decision that affects your bottom line. Many business owners wrestle with whether to do payroll themselves with software like Gusto, or to hire a professional service like us. While handling it on your own might look cheaper at first, the truth is, the cost involves more than just dollars and cents.

With over twenty years of payroll experience, we know both options' ins and outs.

This article breaks down the real costs involved with DIY versus professional payroll services, making it easier for you to choose the right path for your business.

The Hidden Costs of Doing Payroll Yourself

Saving Money Now Might Cost You More Later

Choosing a DIY payroll solution might seem cost-effective because of the lower initial price. However, the potential hidden costs can sneak up on you. Think about it like doing your taxes on your own versus hiring an accountant. You might save on the accountant's fee, but miss out on a larger tax refund that only an expert could help you get.

  • Compliance Risks: Handling payroll by yourself can lead to mistakes in tax filings or not following labor laws correctly. These errors can result in big fines or legal issues from incorrect employee payments.
  • Time Costs: The time you spend figuring out payroll is time away from running your business. This can mean lost opportunities to make money or improve your business.

The Advantages of Professional Payroll Services

Expert Help Can Save Money and Stress

Professional payroll services do more than just run numbers. They bring expertise and peace of mind, ensuring your payroll is done right and keeping up with the latest tax rules.

  • Avoiding Penalties: Professionals help avoid costly mistakes that lead to fines or penalties.
  • Keeping Up-to-Date: Payroll rules change often. Professional services manage these updates for you, ensuring your business stays in line with the law without extra effort from you.
  • Efficiency: Professional services manage payroll for many companies at once, which makes their process more efficient. They pass these savings on to you.

Cost Comparison: DIY vs. Professional

Here's a simple breakdown to show how DIY and professional services stack up:

Aspect DIY Payroll Professional Services
Initial Setup Cost Low Moderate
Ongoing Management High (time + mistakes) Lower (handled by pros)
Compliance Risks High Low
Potential Penalties High Minimal


This comparison shows that professional services might cost more upfront but typically lead to greater savings and fewer problems down the road.

What's Best for You and Your Business?

When deciding between DIY and professional payroll services, think beyond the immediate costs. Consider the long-term effects on your business’s finances and legal standing. Investing in professional payroll services means investing in your business's smooth operation and peace of mind.

 Need help with your payroll? Use our instant pricing calculator to get an estimate for the cost of our full-service payroll services.

Get Your Instant Price

If you found this article helpful, here are some others you might like:


Are You Paying Too Much?

Send us your payroll invoice and get a FREE 10 min call to see if you’re getting ripped off.


Do you have ITIN workers?

Are you upset because your payroll company can't help?


How Much Does It Cost?

See detailed pricing now for each service without talking to a salesperson.

Baron can lighten my workload and increase my profitability?
Let’s talk shop.

Book Time With Bill Elkins